Court Refuses to Stay Its Decision Striking Down Virginiafs Same-Sex Marriage Ban
By ALAN BLINDER
AUG. 13, 2014 - New York Times
The federal appeals court that last
month struck down Virginiafs ban on same-sex unions refused Wednesday to
delay the effects of its ruling. State officials said that unless the United
States Supreme Court interceded, Virginia counties could begin issuing marriage
licenses to gay couples next week.
The United States Court of Appeals
for the Fourth Circuit, in Richmond, Va., voted 2-to-1 in July to uphold
a Federal District Courtfs ruling
in February that Virginiafs ban, which voters approved in 2006, was invalid. In
another 2-to-1 ruling announced Wednesday, the court said it would not stay its
decision. The judges who voted to deny the stay, Henry F. Floyd and Roger L.
Gregory, did not explain their reasoning.
The banfs supporters quickly said
they would appeal the Fourth Circuitfs decision on the stay to the Supreme
Court, which has already received an appeal of the Richmond panelfs July
opinion.
gThe people of Virginia and every
other state should continue to be free to preserve marriage as the union of one
man and one woman in their laws if they choose to do so,h said Byron Babione,
senior counsel for Alliance Defending Freedom, which represents a Prince William
County court clerk who supports the ban.
Legal observers widely expect the
Supreme Court to block enforcement of the decision to end the Virginia ban on
same-sex marriage, as
it did in Utah after courts declared that statefs marriage restrictions
unconstitutional. Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., who oversees the Fourth
Circuit, can render a decision alone or refer requests for action to the full
court.
Many legal experts expect the
Supreme Court to take up the issue of same-sex marriage in its next term, which
begins in October.
If the Supreme Court does not
issue a temporary stay, the Fourth Circuitfs ruling could upend bans on same-sex
marriage in three other states in its jurisdiction: North Carolina, South
Carolina and West Virginia. The circuitfs fifth state, Maryland, has recognized
same-sex marriages for more than a year.
Unless the Supreme Court reverses
the Fourth Circuitfs decision, the Virginia ban will dissolve on Aug. 20,
allowing clerks across the commonwealth to begin issuing the marriage
licenses.
Attorney General Mark R. Herring
of Virginia, who opposes the ban but was among those seeking a stay of the
Fourth Circuitfs July decision, appeared optimistic on Wednesday that same-sex
unions would ultimately be allowed.
gNo one anticipated we would be
this close this quickly to the day when all Virginians have the right to marry
the person they love,h said Mr. Herring, whose office has warned that removing
the ban before the appellate process is complete could yield greater legal
turmoil. gThat will be a historic day for our commonwealth and a joyous day for
thousands of loving couples.h